Amandala Newspaper Online

Home General Politics Crime Education International Sports Features Editorial Publisher Letters Classified
   Article search: Site Web Last Updated: 30/08/2010 - 10:40 PM Make this site your Homepage e-mail us
Latest news: Sustainable Tourism Program promises upgrade for northern downtown area and Tourism Zone  -  Season of stress  -  From The Publisher  -  Immediate action to fight commercial sexual exploitation of children  -  Is customer health a priority in Chinese “fry chicken?”  -  
Massive court victory for Santa Cruz and Conejo Maya!!
Rating: 4.5 / 5 (8 votes)   Printable version Email to a friend Discuss this article
Posted: 19/10/2007 - 11:53 AM
Author: Colin

It took nearly three hours for Chief Justice, Dr. Abdulai Conteh, to pronounce his judgment. Every step of the way he tightened the noose on the Government of Belize’s case. It became clear that the Mayan brothers and sisters from Toledo rural were marching on to an improbable and astounding victory. Still, even after almost three long hours and nary a plug for the government’s side, the audience remained on guard for the inevitable BUT! It never came.
 
In his ruling on Claim 171, Santa Cruz village versus The Attorney General and the Minister of Natural Resources and Environment, and Claim 172, Conejo village against the same defendants, the Chief Justice of Belize, Honorable Abdulai Conteh, gave judgment in favor of the villages on all counts.
 
The court declared (in summary) that the claimants, the villages of Santa Cruz and Conejo, hold…collective and individual rights in the lands and resources that they have used and occupied according to Maya customary practices and that these rights constitute “property”; that the Maya villages of Santa Cruz and Conejo hold collective title to the lands their members have traditionally used and occupied; that the government determine, demarcate and provide official documentation of these villages’ titles and customary rights…without prejudice to the rights of neighboring Villages; that the defendants (GOB) cease and abstain from any acts that might…affect the existence, value, use or enjoyment of the property located in the geographic area occupied and used by the Maya people of Santa Cruz and Conejo without their informed consent…that in respect to the matter the government also complies with the safeguards of the constitution; that the government…abstain from issuing leases and grants, abstain from issuing any regulations concerning land use, and abstain from issuing any concessions for resource exploitation…including…permits or contracts authorizing logging, prospecting or exploration (include oil), and mining or similar activity.
 
For Mayan rights activist, Cristina Coc, she couldn’t hold back the tears of joy after the hard fought victory in court. Immediately after the case she described herself as being “incredibly excited.” Later that afternoon at a press conference at the Radisson Fort George, a sobered Cristina spoke of the long struggle, declaring that “we expect the GOB to respect the court’s decision”, and remembered her late hero, Julian Cho, and his immortal words: We have been to the mountain. Now the mountain must come to us. And thus it seemed this afternoon.
 
For Mayan rights activist, Gregorio Ch’oc, after declaring himself “extremely happy to see that the Constitution of Belize has protected our rights,” it was all business at the Radisson Fort George later that afternoon as he described the two-decade long “struggle for justice, fairness, and equality”, and his joy at being “able to see the fruits of the struggle.” To loud applause he explained to his eager audience, mostly Maya from Santa Cruz and Conejo who had made the long trip to Belize City from the hills in the deep south, that according to the law the communal lands they have always held “belonged to them”, that the government must demarcate and give title to these communities, and that no leases or development concessions could be granted to anyone without their consent.
 
It took the Chief Justice 67 pages to explain his judgment. He wasn’t impressed with the GOB defendants’ case, presented by Ms. Nichola Cho with Mrs. Andrea McSweeney McKoy. For their part, the Chief Justice wrote, the defendants relied only on the affidavits of public officials, none of whom, with respect, could claim any expertise in Maya history, culture, sociology or land usage and custom.
 
In respect to the claimants, Santa Cruz and Conejo, represented by Ms. Antoinette Moore) the Chief Justice thought that they have put an impressive body of evidence before the Court in the form of both affidavit testimonies and expert reports…In addition to the testimonies of witnesses who are members of the Maya communities in Southern Belize…have as well put in evidence the affidavits and reports of non-Maya witnesses who are eminently qualified in the broad field of Maya studies. These witnesses are familiar with the history, ethnography, customs and usages of the Maya. That is to say, they are expert witnesses.
 
One such affidavit cited was that put together by Gregorio Ch’oc, Cristina Coc, and Martin Chen. In their affidavit, Ch’oc, Coc, and Chen described the Maya people as having inhabited a vast area in Toledo “since time immemorial”; having inhabited the area “long before the arrival of the Spanish…and…British”; that many Maya have been in the area “long before the well-known migrations from Guatemala during the late nineteenth century.”
 
They further explained that Maya communities “have always had an elected village leader in each village who oversees community affairs”…and that “the central values that underlie our relationships with each other and with the land have been maintained…” In their affidavit they expressed the view that “Maya customary rights have the same moral and legal claim to respect as property rights recognized by the British common law and the Belizean statutory regime”… and claim that… “Within Maya villages, communities regulate population growth and maintain social and cultural cohesion through collective decision-making regarding the settlement of new families.”
 
Another key affidavit was submitted by Professor Richard R. Wilk, of Indiana University, who, the Chief Justice declared, struck me as very knowledgeable and competent to speak on the issue of Maya customary land tenure and practices. Mr. Wilk declared that “the basis for the Kekchi and Mopan customary system of land management is the concept of usufruct rights, meaning the land is for those who use it”…and that “families can claim and retain plots over long periods of time in an arrangement that resembles private property.”
 
The Defense seemed to have pitched their tent against the claimants on the principal ground of British sovereignty over British Honduras, the Chief Justice wrote…The argument runs, any claim or title to land the claimants might have had was extinguished by virtue of British sovereignty over the territory…(that Belize’s) independent governments succeeded to the sovereignty that had belonged to the British Crown.
 
After deep and anxious consideration on that specific issue the Chief Justice declared thathe was convinced and fortified by authorities that the acquisition of sovereignty over Belize, first by the Crown and later, by independent governments, did not displace, discharge or extinguish pre-existing interests (of the Mayans) in and rights to land. He further stated: It is manifest that throughout the unfolding drama regarding the territory, first, between Spain and later Guatemala on the one hand, and the British authorities on the other, the Maya people were all the while living on their land.
 
For Mr. Arthur Saldivar, who represented the Government in court today, “the judgment was fair. It involved a serious question whether or not customary land tenure existed for the Maya in Southern Belize in respect to Santa Cruz and Conejo…(the)…judgment reconciles their occupation with the rights of every Belizean under the law.” When asked as to what happens to existing leases and other issuances by the GOB in the area, he pointed out that no law is retroactive.
 
Counsel for villagers from Santa Cruz and Conejo, Ms. Antoinette Moore, was “entirely pleased by the judgment.” She says it: “confirms customary land tenure of the Maya people of Southern Belize and in particular the people of Conejo and Santa Cruz villages.”
 
There were other stars in the courtroom today. Lawyer Wilfred “Sedi” Elrington declared the judgment an “excellent decision”; Professor of Law from the University of Arizona, James Anaya, called it a “historic decision”, and says “it affirms what the Maya people have known all along”; PNP leader from Toledo, Wil Maheia, called it a “great victory for the people of Belize”; and Jerry Enriquez described it as “a victory for the people”…”it was a judicial principle that needed clarification…and the judgment was fair.”
 
Few people in Belize thought the Chief Justice would rule in favor of the Mayas. What does it all mean? Prime Minister Musa has said that he will not preside over the balkanization of Belize. The Mayan leaders identified with the Santa Cruz and Conejo claims have said that they are proud Belizeans, to the bone, and they are misrepresented and hurt whenever they are accused of wanting to separate themselves from The Jewel. In a recent development oil companies have won contracts to prospect for oil over every centimeter of land and sea. Is that balkanization? For those of us who love the roots Maya, and identify with the struggles of people downtrodden by big businesses all over the world, we celebrate the Maya victory in court today. But, what does it all mean?


Last Edition
1st overseas military tests for unmanned chopper in Belize
• Fitted with camera and radar, the Hummingbird flies a 10-mile by 10-mile zone in the Mountain Pine Ridge area, near Central Farm... “In 18 hours, it could fly over Belize I’d say maybe 40 to 50 times...:” Dortch, BDF Chief of Staff.. “Belize could have such a platform from which we could do monitoring and surveillance”
Larry Williams, 71, dies at Northern Regional
• Hip replacement patient suffered from ants biting him in bed; hospital investigation finds “no neglect”... Hosts of KREM Radio’s Wake up Belize Morning Vibes, Evan “Mose” Hyde and Sharon Marin, and many of their listeners were left shocked by a report during the show on Wednesday morning from an Orange Walk woman who alleged negligence of an elderly patient at the Northern Regional Hospital in Orange Walk Town.
Frustrated Cuban climbs prison tank to summon Immigration
• Immigration Director Gareth Murillo told Amandala Thursday that his department is working to see what it can do for Cuban national Pedro Venereo Castro, 44, who remains behind bars a half-a-year after serving out his sentence for coming to Belize illegally.
Henry Patnett, 21, charged with stabbing wife, who was pregnant
• Patnett was charged with attempted murder of wife, but not for death of fetus.. Henry Patnett, 21, a construction worker of #94 Boots Crescent, was this morning arraigned in Magistrate’s Court #1 to answer to charges of wounding, attempted murder, aggravated burglary and two counts of aggravated assault.
Audit details land grab before 2008 general elections
• Bill Lindo claims both PUP and UDP “quitar” lands from him... Every Belizean who has ever tried to get a piece of land knows how frustrating the process can be for the average citizen. According to the government policies, it should take no longer than a month and a half for an application to be processed, but many have complained of being pushed around for years without getting their papers.
Armed robber kills girl, 14
• Three thieves hold up shop; one shoots father and daughter, who dies... 14-year-old Hellen Yu, a student of Edward P. Yorke High School, will not get to see her second year at the school two weeks from now, because she died while undergoing treatment at the Karl Heusner Memorial Hospital for two gunshot wounds she sustained to her lower back.
Protect Belizean businesses from Guatemala
• Your editorial in your mid-week issue hit the nail on the head concerning Guatemala coming to Belize and taking everything from us. You mentioned our Cross Country, The Lion Man, recently Costa Maya, but you forgot to mention our commerce. They’re already doing it, starting with Social Security Punta Gorda Branch with the windows, printing and how about our southern cayes, Ranguana and Sapodilla, which they seem to enjoy and we can’t do anything about it.
GOB “undermining” CriqueSarco project?
• Please publish this letter in your weekly newspaper, concerning the extreme alarm and frustration of the “sustainable forestry group” due to the holdup and delay we are experiencing from commencing with our project here in Crique Sarco Village in Toledo District.
Talk sense, says Randolph Cruz
• I am writing in reference to Miss Garcia’s article on sea cucumbers in your August 1, 2010 issue. I learned some of the technical information concerning the cucumbers; it was interesting.
Here is a copy of a reproduced report on the Battle of St. George’s Caye 1798
• Letters of which the following are copies were yesterday received from the Earl of Balcarras, by His Grace the Duke of Portland, one of his Majesty’s Principal Secretaries of State.
Justice for pregnant woman stabbing?
• The stabbing of a pregnant woman, Valerie Sheran, 28, which occurred last week, made headlines as it was discovered that the woman was in month 7 of her pregnancy and was attacked, allegedly, by her ex-boyfriend and father of her unborn baby, while she reportedly was lying in bed with her current boyfriend, a 70-year-old man, and her daughter, 2.
Belizean reported dead in Afghan war still alive
• Multiple reports in the US press today, Thursday, August 12, claimed that a Sergeant 1st Class Edgar N. Roberts, who was reportedly born in Belize but grew up in Chicago, had died on Tuesday, August 10, after nearly two months of hospitalization from injuries he sustained in Afghanistan, in Operation Enduring Freedom, following a June 26 explosion.
DR. GAYLE’S RESPONSE
• TO THE RESPONSES TO THE MALE SOCIAL PARTICIPATION AND VIOLENCE STUDY... I want to use this medium to respond to the varied responses to the Report – ninety percent of which have been positive, the other 10 percent ranging from misguided to plain disappointing. I want to inform the 10 percent that most of the very shallow things whispered in Belize about the research reached me within 24 hours from people I have never met – strangely not from my research team (that seems to believe that it is better not to inform me of these things).
Subscribe To Amandala
 


Calendar
 
SunMonTueWedThuFriSat
1 2 3 4
5 6 7 8 9 10 11
12 13 14 15 16 17 18
19 20 21 22 23 24 25
26 27 28 29 30

Amandala Weekly Poll
How would you rate our site
Excellent
Good
Not bad
Bad
Poor

Listen To Krem Radio Online

About Us | Advertising | Contact | Subscription Info | Useful Links